Intermediate · Lesson 9
Staking and DeFi: where the yield comes from
Every yield has a payer. If you cannot name who pays and why, the yield is either inflation or your own capital.
The yield card shows one number. Behind it there is a payer, a mechanism and a failure mode. If you cannot name all three, the number is not information yet.
Four payers
Almost every DeFi yield is one of four things:
| Yield | Who pays | What has to keep happening |
|---|---|---|
| Staking rewards | Issuance, plus transaction fees and sometimes MEV | Validators keep producing blocks and the token holds value |
| Lending interest | Borrowers who pay to use your deposit | Borrowers keep borrowing and repaying |
| Trading fees | Traders who swap against a pool | Volume continues and divergence stays below fees |
| Incentives | The protocol's emission, or a treasury | The token holds value and the programme continues |
The first three are tied to activity; the fourth is a subsidy. The line is not always clean — staking rewards paid in new tokens are also dilution — but «who pays?» still separates a business from a schedule.
Staking: paid by issuance and fees
In proof of stake, a validator locks capital, attests to blocks and occasionally proposes one. The protocol pays it in newly issued tokens, which dilute holders, and in transaction fees from users. If you delegate, the validator takes a commission, and you receive the rest. The validator's capital is also at risk: a serious fault can be slashed, and downtime can cost a small penalty.
Two details change the economics: the reward rate is a function of how much is staked and how issuance is scheduled, and your position is illiquid for the unbonding period. A liquid staking token gives you a transferable claim, but it adds a contract, a validator set and a secondary-market price that can trade below the underlying.
Restaking goes one step further: the same capital secures additional services, with additional rewards and slashing conditions. The yield is higher because the risk is higher.
Worked example: the yield and the price
Suppose you stake 100 tokens and the advertised rate is 20% per year, paid in the same token. After a year of simple rewards you have 120 tokens. If the token's price falls 30% over the same period, your position is worth 120 × 0.70 = 84, against 100 at the start. You earned 20% more tokens and lost 16% in dollar terms: 1.20 × 0.70 = 0.84.
Compared with doing nothing, staking still left you better off: 120 tokens × 0.70 = 84 versus 100 × 0.70 = 70. The yield did not protect you from the price; it only changed how many units you held. That is the correct comparison, and not the one the APR suggests.
APR and APY
APR is a nominal annual rate. APY is what you get if the rewards compound. The conversion is simple:
APY = (1 + APR / n)^n − 1
At 12% APR compounded monthly, n = 12: (1 + 0.12/12)^12 − 1 = 1.01^12 − 1 = 12.68%. Compounded daily, (1 + 0.12/365)^365 − 1 = 12.75%. The gap is small at 12% and grows with the rate; comparing an APR from one venue with an APY from another is a category error.
APY also assumes you reinvest. If rewards arrive as a token you leave in a wallet, they do not compound on their own. And if the reward token is not the token you staked, the APY is a claim about two prices, not one.
Lending: the arithmetic of utilisation
A lending pool pays suppliers from interest. The rate depends on utilisation: the share of deposits that is borrowed. Suppose a pool has 1,000,000 dollars supplied and 800,000 borrowed, so utilisation is 80%. If the borrow rate is 6%, borrowers pay 48,000 dollars a year. A 10% reserve factor sends 4,800 to the protocol and 43,200 to suppliers. On 1,000,000 supplied, that is 4.32% before compounding.
The rate is not fixed: if utilisation rises, the borrow rate rises to attract deposits and encourage repayment. If it reaches 100%, withdrawals queue or fail, and the supply rate can look attractive while the exit is closed.
Leverage changes the risk, not the yield: a borrower who supplies 100, borrows 60 and supplies again is running a position that is liquidated if the collateral falls. Suppose 150 dollars of collateral supports 100 dollars of debt with an 80% liquidation threshold. The collateral can fall to 100 / 0.80 = 125 dollars before the position is eligible for liquidation — a fall of 16.7%. At 120 dollars, the contract sells collateral and charges a penalty. The screen did not mention that.
The risks the APR hides
- Smart contract risk: a bug, an upgrade or a malicious admin can take the deposit.
- Oracle risk: a wrong price triggers the wrong liquidation.
- Governance risk: a vote can change collateral factors, fees or the reward schedule.
- Bridge risk: an asset that came across a bridge depends on the bridge.
- Stablecoin risk: a pool quoted in a dollar token is only as stable as that token.
- Liquidity risk: the withdrawal queue is part of the product, even if the dashboard calls it instant.
If the payer is the token's own issuance, the yield is a transfer from future holders to present ones. That can be a rational trade; it is not income.
Check yourself
- A pool advertises 18% APR. Name three payers and one reason each could stop.
- A rate is 10% APR compounded monthly. What is the APY, and what assumption does that number make?
- Why can a loan with 150% collateral be liquidated after a 20% fall in the collateral?
The terms — validator, APR and APY, liquidation, yield farming — are in the glossary. Yield farming, restaking and real yield goes deeper into emissions, and Liquidity pools, DEXs and bridges explains the fee side of the table.